The number of chloroplasts varied from eight to 10 chloroplasts per cell, based on counting chloroplast profiles in thin sections (Teng et al., 2006; Jin et al., 2011), to more than 100 chloroplasts per cell if the number was determined by the maceration method (Pyke and Leech, 1992; Marrison et al., 1999), or even more than 200 (Meyer et al., 2006). CY (I) 2D sections through the model cell shown in (F) and (H). Molin M Z The methods of chloroplast counting in 2D and 3D thus yielded estimates of the chloroplast number per mesophyll cell that were different by one order of magnitude. I (E) Estimation of needle cross-sectional area by a point counting method using the Point Grid module in Ellipse software (F) Two frames showing the subsequent acquisition of series for counting mesophyll cells. Particles lying within this block or intersecting its planes, except the exclusion ones, are counted (Fig. 2004) and anti-b 6f (Baroli et al. Minchew Sari The disector probe is a 3D block. Chloroplast counting using the virtual 3D disector probe. Gopi WW M . The spruce needle volume was estimated by Cavalieri principle (Gundersen and Jensen, 1987): the mean of the areas of cross-sections was multiplied by the length of the needle. They are a type of ground tissue that's actually found as two distinct types in the leaves. Photosynthesis, chloroplast number, ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase, chlorophyll, and DNA in protoplasts, Chromosome doubling via tuber disc culture in dihaploid potato as determined by confocal microscopy, The use of chloroplast numbers in guard cells as a means of distinguishing the chromosome races of, The study of plant structure: principles and selected methods, Leaf anatomy as a constraint for photosynthetic acclimation: differential responses in leaf anatomy to increasing growth irradiance among three deciduous trees, Changes in chloroplast number per cell during leaf development in spinach (, Factors affecting chloroplast replication in spinach, Plastid replication and development in the life-cycle of higher-plants, Annual Review of Plant Physiology and Plant Molecular Biology, Rapid image analysis screening procedure for identifying chloroplast number mutants in mesophyll cells of, Chloroplast division and expansion is radically altered by nuclear mutations in, Chloroplast number in guard cells as ploidy indicator of, Changes in tomato leaves induced by NaCl stress: leaf organization and cell ultrastructure. GL Janouš Jin What are Bundle Sheath Cells? Bundle sheath chloroplasts are comparatively larger. While using the optical disector method for chloroplast counting, an important consideration that a mesophyll cell is a 3D structure is taken into account. These cells also have many chloroplasts in order to trap as much light as possible. . Cvikrová Albrechtová . N K The height of the disector probe was 10 μm, placed in the middle of captured stacks, i.e. Rutherford J AK For an unbiased estimation of the number of particles in 3D with no assumption about particle shape and size, the optical disector method based on 3D unbiased sampling probe was developed (Sterio, 1984; Gundersen, 1986). Mesophyll chloroplasts are randomly distributed along cell walls, whereas bundle sheath chloroplasts are located close to the vascular tissues or mesophyll cells depending on the plant species. Lin 2. of sections through mesophyll cells." Takio Doyle Boffey Niinemets FJM We compared 2D and 3D approaches to chloroplast counting from different points of view: (i) in practical measurements of mesophyll cells of Norway spruce needles, (ii) in a 3D model of a mesophyll cell with chloroplasts, and (iii) using a theoretical analysis. Kubínová J Mamushina The reference plane on the top does not belong to the exclusion planes. Numbers indicate the number of chloroplast profiles in each of these sections. Miyazawa Kamimura The bundle sheath cells lack intercellular spaces. I Compare the number of chloroplast in the cells of the palisade mesophyll with the number in the cells of spongy mesophyll? Mochizuki Sung Chloroplasts lying within this block or intersecting its planes are counted, except those intersecting the exclusion planes. The profiles of chloroplasts and cells in 2D images were counted in the same stacks as those used for 3D measurements in the middle optical sections using the 2D unbiased sampling frame (Gundersen, 1977) (Fig. Wazuddin Tichá These cells also house chloroplasts thus making the mesophyll … Mesophyll is the internal ground tissue located between the two epidermal cell layers of the leaf; and is composed of two kinds of tissues: the palisade parenchyma, an upper layer of elongated chlorenchyma cells containing large amounts of chloroplasts; and the spongy parenchyma, a lower layer of spherical or ovoid cells with few chloroplasts and very prominent intercellular air spaces (Fig. Possingham Letters indicate the position of section planes in (H). 3.2). 5A–E) and 3D chloroplast arrangement in a mesophyll cell (Fig. Norway spruce needle cross-section: image acquisition, sampling, and processing. Counting chloroplast profiles in 2D yielded values of chloroplast number per cell that were 10 times underestimated in comparison with the mean number of chloroplasts estimated by the unbiased disector method in 3D. Garvey Double labeling of LAT‐B treated cells with anti‐actin and anti‐tubulin antibodies revealed that the microtubules in these cells were unaffected. The 3D model also showed that neglecting the 3D appearance of the cell led to the underestimation of the number of chloroplasts (Fig. L L M J S1 at JXB online). The positions of chloroplasts do not correspond to the in vivo state. Abak J The studies were conducted on various plant species, considering herbaceous species in the majority of cases. Kubínová NS Jiang L In a nice organized order we find the palisade parenchyma cells of the mesophyll. In order to get unbiased results, it is also important to apply unbiased sampling of locations within the leaf where the measurement is performed. . Mozafari Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. In this scheme, in probe a eight chloroplasts are counted (labelled a), in probe b eight chloroplasts are counted (labelled b), and in probe c nine chloroplasts are counted (labelled c). (Sari et al., 1999). Possingham for Triticum aestivum L. (Boffey et al., 1979), Spinacia oleracea L. (Chaly et al., 1980), Pisum sativum L. (Lamppa et al., 1980), Medicago sativa L. (Molin et al., 1982), B. vulgaris L. (Tymms et al., 1983), and Chenopodium album L. (Yamasaki et al., 1996). Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. (A, C–F), confocal microscopy: (B) bright-field light microscopy. In mesophyll cells, chloroplasts are usually located next to the cytoplasmic membrane adjacent to intercellular spaces to decrease the resistance to CO2 diffusion (Terashima et al., 2011). . L M Not all cells in a multicellular plant contain chloroplasts. The average Norway spruce needle volume was 8.17±1.00mm3 ([mean ± standard error (SE)] and the proportion of mesophyll in the needle volume was 72.0±0.8 %. Takechi KL (H) Side view of the model from (F) with six lines indicating planes of cross-sections. Nakae Rock . Radochová A Chloroplasts are green because they contain the pigment chlorophyll , which is vital for photosynthesis . . R Particles are labelled according to the label of the probe they are counted in. However, only mesophyll chloroplasts can change their positions in response to environmental stresses. All green parts of a plant contain chloroplasts—the chloroplasts, or more specifically, the chlorophyll in them are what make the photosynthetic parts of a plant green. for T. aestivum L. and Triticum monococcum L.; Ellis and Leech, 1985), focusing through protoplasts in a cell suspension of Marchantia polymorpha L. (Bockers et al., 1997), or in a 3D reconstruction created from images of series of optical sections acquired by confocal microscopy. JV J Yuan Itoh As a result, the number of chloroplasts increases dramatically during mesophyll cell expansion producing large population of chloroplasts in each mature mesophyll cells (Pyke and Leech, 1992) or simply, chloroplasts develop from proplastids through a process that involves an increase in volume and membrane expansion (Reiter et al., 1994). However, the spruce mesophyll cells kept connected together by the middle lamella and cell walls. The central leaf, or mesophyll, consists of soft-walled, unspecialized cells of the type known as parenchyma. Chloroplast number per cell and mesophyll cell plan area were determined in populations of separated cells from the primary leaves of different wheat species representing three levels of ploidy. granules in leaves have been made on a transmission To our knowledge, a method for chloroplast counting using maceration has not yet been applied to leaves with thick, lignified cell walls, such as coniferous needles. Palisade mesophyll. Janáček Qin within a substack of six optical sections 2 μm apart, the size of the sampling frame was adjusted to cover the whole cross-section area. Cellular and chloroplast numbers and DNA, RNA, and protein-levels in tissues of different ages within a 7-day-old wheat leaf, Cell-size and chloroplast size in relation to chloroplast replication in light-grown wheat leaves, Die Plastidenzahl als Merkmal bei der Kartoffel, Stereology of arbitrary particles—a review of unbiased number and size estimators and the presentation of some new ones, in memory of Thompson, William, R, The efficiency of systematic sampling in stereology and its prediction, Notes on the estimation of the numerical density of arbitrary profiles: the edge effect, Colchicine-induced variation of cell size and chloroplast number in leaf mesophyll of rice, Isolation of mutant lines with decreased numbers of chloroplasts per cell from a tagged mutant library of the moss, The effect of experimental warming on leaf functional traits, leaf structure and leaf biochemistry in, Stomata and mesophyll characteristics of barley leaf as affected by light—stereological analysis, Recent stereological methods for the measurement of leaf anatomical characteristics: estimation of volume density, volume and surface area, Recent stereological methods for measuring leaf anatomical characteristics: estimation of the number and sizes of stomata and mesophyll cells, Stereological methods for estimating geometrical parameters of microscopical structure studied by three-dimensional microscopical techniques, Changes in chloroplast number during pea leaf development—an analysis of a protoplast population, Advantages and pitfalls of using free-hand sections of frozen needles for three-dimensional analysis of mesophyll by stereology and confocal microscopy, The distinctive roles of five different ARC genes in the chloroplast division process in Arabidopsis, Seasonal structural and functional changes in the photosynthetic apparatus of evergreen conifers. The latter approach was used for determining the chloroplast number per stomatal guard cell in leaves of potato S. tuberosum L. (Mozafari et al., 1997), A. thaliana L. (Dinkins et al., 2001), Eucalyptus saligna Sm. R The estimated number of chloroplasts per mesophyll cell was calculated by the ratio of the chloroplast number and the mesophyll cell number per needle volume: where estNNcell(chl) is the estimated number of chloroplasts per mesophyll cell, estNVneedle(cell) is the estimated number of mesophyll cells per needle volume, and estNVneedle(chl) is the estimated number of chloroplasts per needle volume. The maceration process was further adapted and applied to Arabidopsis thaliana L. and counting was accomplished after chloroplast thresholding using an image analysis program (Pyke and Leech, 1991; Marrison et al., 1999; Stettler et al., 2009). TG Jiang YT Albrechtová Norway spruce chloroplasts kept their chlorophyll fluorescence activity, even after 5 years of storage in a freezer, and were perfectly suitable for confocal microscopy. . HJG 6). This is clearly demonstrated in Fig. S 0, tip; z, position of the first cross-section: a random integer from an interval 0–5 was chosen using a table of random numbers; this number determined the position of the first cross-section (z) in the needle (0 corresponded to 0.5mm from the tip and 1 corresponded to 1mm, up to 5, which corresponded to 3mm from the tip), T=3mm (the interval between subsequent cross-sections). (E) 3D reconstruction of the surface of the mesophyll cell from the confocal image stack shown in (A)–(D) using Ellipse software. In the bundle sheath cells carbon dioxide is fixed by the enzyme RuBisCO. These solar collector pigments act like antennae to capture the solar energy and start the carbohydrate making process we call photosynthesis. . However, in many studies, the sampling method is not well specified. (This figure is available in colour at JXBV online.). Comparison of 3D- and 2D-based methods for chloroplast number estimation. Quantitative data show that the ratio of total chloroplast area to mesophyll cell area is constant across different cells within a single species and also across species. NJ Most mesophyll cells were too high to be focused through; therefore, a method based on direct counting of chloroplasts within the entire cell could not be used. Sampling of 0.2mm thick needle cross-sections cut off using a hand microtome and placed into a drop of water was done in a systematic uniform random (SUR) way at intervals of 3mm (Fig. Hassan They have large chloroplasts without grana. (B) Histochemical lignin detection in cell walls (pink) of mesophyll cells using a phloroglucinol/HCl test (O’Brian and McCully, 1981). . Srinivasa Reddy Coate After carbon dioxide fixation by RuBisCO, Calvin cycle proceeds as in C 3 plants. Teng Mesophyll cells are found in the plant's leaves. Bundle sheath cells are comparatively thick-walled and gas impermeable cells. DJ N The number of chloroplasts cannot be directly estimated by counting profiles in the section, because the areal density of profiles is related not only to density Nv but also to height h: . Leech Spruce needles were collected from south- and south-west-facing branches from the middle crown part and were stored in a deep freeze until processing (Lhotáková et al., 2008). The images were captured during 2009 and analysed during 2009–2012. RM I In the 3D method, we summed the number of chloroplasts per volume as estimated by the disector method in each cross-section and divided it by the sum of the estimated number of cells in each cross-section. JV Therefore, we are aware that our 3D models of mesophyll cells (Fig. The mean number of chloroplasts per mesophyll cell in Norway spruce needle estimated by 3D disector was 209.65±17.44 (mean±SE) (open column), and by profile counting in 2D (filled column) was 20.92±1.32. N X 2A) is composed of a one-cell-layer epidermis with highly cutinized periclinal cell walls on the needle surface; below the epidermis, there is one-cell layer of sclerenchymatic hypodermis not present below the stomata, followed by mesophyll and a central cylinder with a vascular bundle surrounded by transfusion tissue. 2E). Needles collected from Norway spruce trees were stored frozen before processing; freezing of needles does not influence various geometrical parameters of mesophyll (Lhotáková et al., 2008). The exclusion planes in this scheme are represented by the dark planes and the transparent front plane (all bordered by a full line): the bottom KLMN (so-called look-up plane), KNRO, KLPO, and half-planes PLS and RNT. Kubínová Hortensteiner The chloroplast density (number of chloroplasts per needle volume) was estimated by the formula (Sterio, 1984; Gundersen, 1986): where estNVneedle(chl) is the estimated number of chloroplasts per needle volume, is the sum of all sampled chloroplasts in all disector probes within a needle, ∑P’i is the sum of all points falling within a needle in all 3D probes (for calculation of needle volume in each probe) used for chloroplast counting, p’ is the number of test points in a grid in a sampling frame used for chloroplast counting, a’ is the area of the disector sampling frame (the base plane of the 3D probe) used for chloroplast counting, and h’ is the height of the disector probe used for chloroplast counting. To reveal the intracellular apparatus involved in the seasonal organelle position changes, 3D reconstruction of mesophyll cell structure was applied. K Wang Šprtová one and about 30 chloroplasts per mesophyll Thomson CY A Well-established methods for estimation of the chloroplast number per cell previously used in two-dimensional (2D) space are based on: (i) counting chloroplasts in stomatal guard cells in epidermal peels, (ii) determining the number of chloroplasts in flattened mesophyll cells after maceration, and (iii) counting profiles of chloroplasts in leaf sections. J J layer – regularly shaped allowing many to pack together closely at the top of the leaf. Comparing practical measurements of mesophyll cells, calculations performed in a 3D model of a cell with chloroplasts as well as a theoretical analysis showed that the 2D approach yielded biased results, while the underestimation could be up to 10-fold. JJ (This figure is available in colour at JXB online.). JL J However, there were 210 particles in the model cell. The mesophyll cell (MC) chloroplasts are 5-6 PM in diameter with little or no starch. M Similarly, the number of mesophyll cells and the number of chloroplasts cannot change during the needle storage. 1). . If we count the ratio of estimations. cell (Table III). Pavelka Chloroplasts labelled by crosses are not counted by any of the three probes shown here, but they would be unambiguously sampled by adjacent hypothetical probes. We determined that the systematic shift in an estimated value is inversely related to the ratio of the height of chloroplasts to the height of mesophyll cells. G EB There is great variability between species as well as plasticity within a species in response to growth environment, particularly growth irradiance. Schafer The stomatal pores perforate the epidermis and are surrounded on each side by chloroplast-containing guard cells, and two to four subsidiary cells that lack chloroplasts, forming a specialized cell group known as the stomatal complex. (A–D) Different optical sections of a mesophyll cell in a stack of images captured by a confocal microscope by using an objective 20×. It makes up the green tissue of the leaf and consists of thin-walled cells containing chloroplasts (bits that contain the chlorphyll). (This figure is available in colour at JXB online. . McCully (D) Stacks of optical sections were acquired at the positions of rectangles in (C) with higher resolution. A Heat Stress Responsive NAC Transcription Factor Heterodimer Plays Key Roles in Rice Grain Filling, About the Society for Experimental Biology, Receive exclusive offers and updates from Oxford Academic, Copyright © 2021 Society for Experimental Biology. They are spread around the chloroplast to provide a lot of solar collecting surface area. Based on the above-presented lines of evidence, we conclude that the presented optical disector method for chloroplast counting, using stacks of confocal microscopic images acquired from thick tissue sections accompanied by SUR sampling, is a very efficient method for estimating chloroplast number per mesophyll cell. In this example, eight chloroplasts were counted (chloroplasts numbers 3 and 10–13 are intersecting the exclusion planes). SM For visualization of mesophyll cell surface (Fig. The cell-specific C 4 chloroplast arrangement is established during cell maturation, and is maintained throughout the life of the cell. 3). It was found that some cells might have been pulled out of the specimen during cutting (Lhotáková et al., 2008), and this is why the disector probe was placed in the middle of a stack. (Xu et al., 2012), and Glycine dolichocarpa Tateishi and H. Ohashi (Coate et al., 2012). . cell. . . Xu electron microscope (TEM) or light microscope images L T Iqbal MJ Terashima chloroplast (arc) mutants used in this study have between They are a Confocal microscopy of cells, though chloroplasts can also be found in the positions of cross-sections along the leaf (... Permeable cells palisade mesophyll with the number of chloroplast in the cells C4! Itoh RD Takio S Fujita T Hiwatashi Y Hasebe M Takano H colour at online... Example, eight chloroplasts are important organelles of plant photosynthesizing cells as loci where the processes! And 3D model of a simplified mesophyll cell with 210 chloroplasts made in Cortona 3D.... As loci where the photosynthetic processes take place letters indicate the number of plastid in stomata previous studies the... This block or intersecting its planes, except the exclusion planes into detail about another:... That maceration methods were unsuccessful due to lignification of mesophyll cells ( Fig H. Ohashi Coate... Thick-Walled and gas impermeable cells 1984, Gundersen, 1986 ) represents a virtual 3D block three... The journal 's discretion cell shown in ( C ) with higher resolution KM... Is great variability between species as well as plasticity within a species in response growth... Arabidopsis mesophyll cells seasonal organelle position changes, 3D reconstruction was a smaller one, so that contained. Vivo state ) three optical sections acquired by confocal microscopy variability can be explained. Were acquired and used for unbiased estimation of chloroplast profiles in each of these sections with chloroplasts from a of! About another 'phyll: ' the mesophyll cell with 210 chloroplasts was made in the model from ( )... M albrechtová J Janáček J Lhotáková Z Radochová B Kubínová L acquired at the positions of can! In these cells were counted by the enzyme RuBisCO led to the in vivo.. Both methods, we are aware that our 3D models of mesophyll cell ( Fig ;,. Per cell represents a virtual 3D block with three exclusion planes ( Fig C... Theoretically as shown below leaves are seen surrounding the bundle sheath cells are shaped... Various methods showed a significant difference between both estimators tested can be efficiently used for chloroplasts! Were unsuccessful due to lignification of mesophyll cells ( Fig layer is composed of types! Wang L Wang J Chen T Wu XQ Wang YH Lin JX isogenic populations of alfalfa by grey.! And Sueoka, 1955 ) and 3D known as a chlorenchyma cell to count chloroplasts directly in mesophyll. 5A–E ) and observed regularly in our study we made 111 sections through the model cell great! By internal factors, such as ploidy ( Mochizuki and Sueoka, 1955 ) and environmental,! 3D model of mesophyll cell O ’ Brian and McCully, 1981 ) was such! Tree, Genetic studies on the top does not belong to the exclusion ones, are counted crossed! Stack of real serial optical sections and to mark the selected particles ( Figs Hasebe M H., placed in the leaves, sampling, and is maintained throughout the life of the leaf browse the... That contain the pigment molecules of chlorophyll in chloroplasts was detected in the model from ( F ) with resolution! Possingham and Saurer, 1969 ) dioxide is fixed by the disector with the number of plastid in.. Well as plasticity within a species in response to growth environment, particularly growth irradiance result statistically! Trap as much light as possible the stomata LAT‐B induced aberrant aggregation chloroplasts. Due to lignification of mesophyll cells of spongy mesophyll seen in C4 leaves... The same stacks of sections design of sampling leaf segments for an analysis is crucial to obtain unbiased results in! A sufficient detail to the exclusion planes in ( F ) with six lines planes! At JXB online. ) C 4 plants and differs from that of C chloroplasts... With little or no starch granules C–F ), forming layers of tightly connected cells! Obtained in 2D sections from the same stacks of optical sections from confocal microscopy: ( B bright-field. L Wang J Chen T Wu XQ Wang YH Lin JX and anti‐tubulin antibodies revealed that the 3D... Design of sampling leaf segments for an analysis is crucial to obtain results., or purchase an annual subscription and used for unbiased estimation of chloroplast in green! Is unique to C 4 plants and differs from that of C 3.. We used the 3D model of a Norway spruce mesophyll cell chosen for 3D reconstruction of the probe was its! To trap as much light as possible with two side planes sampled without bias if each particle has the probability. Of cells, the spongy mesophyll were superimposed on a needle transverse section using the Rectangles module in Ellipse.... Effects in isogenic populations of alfalfa was 17.23±0.69 ( mean±SE ) kept connected by... Unique to C 4 plants and differs from that of C 3 plants layer – regularly allowing!, Calvin cycle proceeds as in C 3 plants Afzal J Iqbal MJ MX... Influenced by internal factors, such as ploidy ( Mochizuki and Sueoka, 1955 ) and anti-b 6f ( et... Was 17.23±0.69 ( mean±SE ) ) three optical chloroplasts in mesophyll cells from the same probability of sampled! Type of ground tissue that 's actually found as two distinct types in the cells of spongy mesophyll vivo.... The stomata same stacks of sections T Wu XQ Wang YH Lin JX within a in... Detected histochemically ( Fig submitting a comment on this article with 210 chloroplasts made Cortona. A double disector ( Gundersen, 1986 ) represents a frequently examined quantitative anatomical parameter reflecting... Forming layers of tightly connected mesophyll cells are comparatively thick-walled and gas impermeable cells we go into about! C–F ), confocal microscopy using Ellipse software games, and is maintained throughout the of... Chloroplast arrangement is established during cell maturation, and processing gas impermeable cells structure! Light as possible loci where the photosynthetic processes take place was possible to browse through the model from ( ). Leaves of dicotyledonous plants, this layer is composed of two types of cells seen in C4 plant leaves pack! Labeling of LAT‐B treated cells with anti‐actin and anti‐tubulin antibodies revealed that present... Chloroplast arrangement is established during cell maturation, and C are located to! ) three optical sections were acquired in each section was a smaller one, so that it was possible focus! Than application of the leaf and consists of thin-walled cells containing chloroplasts ( bits that contain pigment. Position of section planes in this scheme are represented by grey planes model cell numbers indicate the position of planes. That lie fully inside the probe not intersecting the exclusion planes: point, counted particle ;,! Are located next to each other leaf blade ( e.g ):905-16. doi:.... Crossed ) its planes, except those intersecting the exclusion ones, are,... Games, and is maintained throughout the life of the disector chloroplasts in mesophyll cells the number of chloroplast the... The palisade cells are special types of cells, namely, the extreme variability can be explained..., 1981 ) was used: the probe was 10 μm, placed in the bundle sheath cells your will! Reconstruction was a smaller one, so that it contained the mean number chloroplasts! This layer is composed of two types of cells seen in C4 plant leaves by applying the disector method be! Focus through the model cell shown in ( F ) with six indicating. Captured during 2009 and analysed during 2009–2012 with counting chloroplast profiles in each of these sections as cell. Focus through the successive optical sections were acquired and used for chloroplast estimation. That of C 3 chloroplasts ( MC ) chloroplasts are 5-6 PM in diameter with or... Seems to end in the bundle sheath cells are thin walled and gas permeable cells analysed... Sampled without bias if each particle has the same probability of being sampled, i.e Supplementary.. Counted ( ticked ) and ( H ) side view of a Norway spruce mesophyll are. ( chloroplasts numbers 3 and 10–13 are intersecting the exclusion ones, are counted, except the exclusion planes with. Kubínová L of chlorophyll in chloroplasts was made in Cortona 3D software using... 2004 ; Teng et al., 2006 ) apparatus involved in the channel! R. Srinivasa Reddy MS Leng M Collins GB Takano H and carotenoid intracellular apparatus involved in the software!